Peer Reviewer Instructions

 The blind review process is the review system adopted by Hammurabi journal. All review steps are completely electronic.  Reviewers should read the criteria for assessing the suitability of submission for publication in the Journal, which may include instructions for preparing an effective and useful review.  Reviewers will have the opportunity to provide the author and editor specific comments as well as separate editor-only comments.  The reviewers will be required to comply with the Competing Interest Disclosure Policy.

 Reviewer Guidelines

 Please consider the following points:

 1- Is the research within the scope of the Hammurabi magazine?

 2- Is the data original and not yet published elsewhere?

 3 -Is the title appropriate and concise?

 4- Does the abstract represent the content of the research?

 5-Is the topic presented objectively?

 6- Are the explanations justified?

 7- Are the analysis and conclusions supported by the results?

 8- Are scholarly sources cited appropriately and comprehensively?

 9- Are the tables and figures clear and related to the research topic?

 10- Should some parts of the research be modified, expanded, or deleted?

 Comments can be entered in the form of texts in the comment field (comments for authors and those for editors only can be entered in two different sections). You can also upload edited files.

 Please provide a recommendation (acceptance; accepted with making adjustments; resubmit for review; submit elsewhere; rejection; see comments).